With this “relational dimension,” the Traditional Free Will Defense morphs into the Relational Free Will Defense. Real love requires libertarian choice, and real libertarian choice entails the possibility of saying “no” to love. The alternative—a world in which everyone lacks the libertarian power to say “no” to love—would indeed be a world devoid of moral evil. However, it would simultaneously be a relationally vacuous world, no more loving than a warehouse full of computers. In the words of Simone